
With their recent breakup becoming official this year, it seems The White Stripes will become known as Jack White's first project. Now, he is a brand unto himself, and has been seen as part of The Raconteurs, Dead Weather, writing James Bond songs, and guesting on Danger Mouse's Rome project. I wanted to take a look back the final White Stripes album, Icky Thump.
While Icky Thump was meant to be a return to the original punk, blues, garage rock fusion of the band's sound after some disappointment with a more experimental Get Behind Me Satan. However, much of the album also introduces more pieces and influences, like Scottish folk, bagpipes, trumpets and some avant-garde elements. As is Jack White's preference, the album was recorded to tape, although this is the only White Stripes album to use 16-track recording (rather than the usual 8-track), allowing some more freedom in cutting takes together and the recording of the various parts.
Thematically, the record is about role-reversals and twists. Many of the songs on the album show a role reversal in a relationship, like "Conquest," or "I'm Slowly Turning Into You," or things that hurt done nicely, "Prickly Thorn, But Sweetly Worn," or the change between cause and effect, "you can't be a pi mp and a pro stit ue too," and of course the entirety of "Effect and Cause."
The album opens with the song "Icky Thump," a corruption of the phrase "Ecky Thump," which is apparently a common Northern England expression, popularized by an episode of The Goodies. While some claimed the spelling change was due to copyright concerns, Jack White offers that it was changed to make the pronunciation clearer to Americans, similar to Led Zeppelin dropping the 'a' from their name.
The stream of consciousness lyrics differentiate "Icky Thump" from other White Stripes singles, and "Thump" also stands out a rare political song by Jack White. Here he is commenting on US immigration policies: "White Americans/What? Nothin' better to do?/Why don't you kick yourself out/You're an immigrant too." And of course the video ends with Mexican workers building the Great Wall to keep themselves out. Musically, the opens with a appropriate thumping and drone, then crescendos into a monster riff just after the first verse. The song also features a great keyboard part, sounding somewhere between an organ and a snake charmer. This is just a beast of a song, and one of the best opening tracks ever.
The second track, "You Don't Know What Love Is (You Just Do You're Told)" dials back the intensity a little, and moves to a Country & Western type sound populated with lyrics that could be borrowed from 70's Dylan. This is an anti-love song, and it's a great one because it's not angry, or even particularly hurt. It's just one guy callin' it how he sees it, and it's not her fault, she just doesn't know what love is. The concern mixed with indifference breathes a new life into an obvious song topic. Fantastic.
"300 MPH Torrential Outpour Blues," is a straightforward blues song, almost. White has described the song as trying to use as many styles of blues as possible in one song. It starts off really low key and mellow, but explodes with guitar at seemingly random intervals. And it features one of my favorite lyrics (which also happens to play with Jack White's fascination with color): “There’s all kinds of redheaded women that I ain’t supposed to kiss. And it’s that color which never fails to turn me blue.”
The next track is one of those rare songs that I can immediately recall my initial listening to, because that's how insane this thing is. I remember buying this album the day it was released, and loading it onto my iPod, listening to it on the Metro on the way to work, and this song's mariachi trumpet explodes into my earbuds. I wanted to blast it out into the Metro car, so everyone could experience the insanity I was hearing. And that song is "Conquest," a Corky Robbins penned song (made most previously famous by Patti Page) about gender role reversal.
One thing that makes this song special is the aforementioned mariachi trumpet, played by Regulo Aldama. He played the part multiple times, and it was overdubbed to make it sound like an entire trumpet section. Also standing out are Jack White's amazing vocals, which soar to astounding heights of pure ridiculous awesome. There are also Spanish and 'Acoustic Mariachi' versions of this song also recorded by the Stripes, which are worth checking out. I think Jess at Apropos of Something still put it best almost four years ago when he first listened to the album and said, "this track sounds like one of those bizarre pieces of music that Quentin Tarantino digs up to stick in his movies."
I feel like "Bone Broke" was a song Jack White put on the record just to hedge all the fans who complained the Stripes weren't heavy enough. It's a solid song, and fun to shout along to, but it's not as experimental as the rest of the record. The same could be said of "Little Cream Soda," which is literally a back to basics recording as it was an older White Stripes song that was never studio recorded.
The two tracks in between those, "Prickly Thorn, But Sweetly Worn," and "St. Andrew (This Battle Is in the Air)," form what I call "An Avant-Garde Scottish Interlude," as they both reference Jack and Meg's shared Scottish heritage. "Prickly Thorn" references thistles, a national emblem of Scotland, and St. Andrew is Scotland's patron saint. "Prickly Thorn" is a great song, and I love the guitar work, and also the yodel-like refrain, which seems to get stuck in my head whenever I listen to it. "St. Andrew," on the other hand, is the oddest and most avant-garde track on the album. I usually love Meg's vocals, but this song sounds like The Beatles' "Revolution 9" as redone by a demonic child. It's still interesting and worth listening to (some great bagpipes feature too), but ultimately it doesn't pan out. Luckily it's a lot shorter than "9."
Ahh, "Rag and Bone!" This is probably my second favorite song on the album, if not for the plausible absurdity of Jack and Meg casting themselves as rag and bone collectors, with hilarious spoken word dialogue between the verses giving this a really unique take. Once I heard Jack say, "Meg, look at this place. Well, this place is a like a mansion! It’s like a mansion! Look at all this stuff!” I was completely sold on adoring this song.
Continuing on the theme of reversal, "I'm Slowly Turning Into You" is a great song about a part of long-term relationships (like marriage) that often goes overlooked: the couple slowly turns into something else, almost a separate entity. Usually this would be presented as a conflict, but the reversal, is that he is "proud" to turn into her. I'd also like to highlight the unsung hero of The White Stripes' sound: Meg's drumming. Jack gets all the praise for his inventiveness and guitar playing, but Meg's low key drumming is what helps put the emphasis on it properly, and not have it drown is some sort of ego match.
Both "A Martyr For My Love For You" and "Catch Hell Blues" feature pretty interesting lyrics, and nice guitar work, but easily could fit in on any other White Stripes album. The last bit of specialness is in the closer, "Effect and Cause." It's a nice little acoustic number, and probably the best White Stripes song where most of the emphasis is on the lyrics. This is a great song, and feels just as much at home in the car, or being strummed by a campfire. Awesome.
Whew, that was a long one. And to think I could spend another 500 words on the B-sides(!), which are better than most album's A-material! Icky Thump is a fantastic album, and easily my favorite album by The White Stripes (though I came pretty late to the game, and it really took the first Raconteurs album to get me interested. Yes I am weird, and quite probably an idiot. But I learn. I digress). I highly recommend it, something for everyone.
Album of the Week appears every Wednesday at Silberwhatever. Each week I discuss an album in context of influence, artistic merit, and whatever else seems slightly relevant. Suggest an album by commenting below or tweeting @ me!